An essay in deontic logic

His best known article from this period is entitled The Myth of Progress, and it questions whether our apparent material and technological progress can really be considered " progress ". Chisholm attributes the idea's endorsement to Nicolai Hartmann as well. Hansson develops systems of deontic logic where he analyzes prohibitive and prescriptive deontic notions in terms of abstract properties of various preference orderings e.

It is often thought that performative utterances generally work this way Kempson A as "A ought to be the case". See Belnapand its references to prior papers. In the last year of his life, among his other honorary degrees, he held an honorary degree at the University of Bergen.

In keeping with very wide trends in logic over the past century or so, we will treat both modal notions and deontic notions as sentential or propositional operators unless otherwise stated. Each reading of the original quartet violates one of our desiderata: For suppose something was obligatory, say OBp.

So we must either construe 2 so that is does not satisfy modus ponens or we must reject OB-RM. This is in contrast to the branching-time approach to deontic contexts in Belnap with Paul Barthawhere agential obligation is a componential compound of an agency operator and an obligation operator one in turn analyzed via an Andersonian-Kangerian reduction.

Smiley is a landmark in the comparative study of such deontic systems. Thomason b, a are classics arguing for the general importance of layering deontic logic on top of temporal logic.

See the entry on modal logic. Other variations[ edit ] Many other varieties of deontic logic have been developed, including non-monotonic deontic logics, paraconsistent deontic logics, and dynamic deontic logics.

Some have suggested this is a problem stemming from scope difficulties, others have argued that the problem is that OB-RM is in fact invalid, and rejecting it solves the problem. The first is analytic philosophy and philosophical logic in the Anglo-American vein.

Again, it does not follow from the fact that our agent leaves something open that it is open per se. It is quite plausible to think that the first five agential operators satisfy the conditions of the traditional square and the traditional threefold classification scheme: Jones contains an influential argument against any temporal-based general solution to the puzzle.

Georg Henrik von Wright

Hansson develops systems of deontic logic where he analyzes prohibitive and prescriptive deontic notions in terms of abstract properties of various preference orderings e. Whether or not these obligations are both all-things-considered-non-overridden obligations is a further issue.

To minimize complications, we will assume no one else can do these things for me.

Deontic Logic

Bibliography[ edit ] Von Wright's home on Laivurinkatu street, Helsinki: These permissions in fact appear to be equivalent to the negations of 1 and 2. Equivalently, it is required that only permissible things are true:Another alternative to the major trend above, one that would unfortunately also take us too far afield, is the adaptation of modal logics for representing computer programs (e.g., dynamic logic) to represent actions in deontic logic.

Georg Henrik von Wright (Swedish: His books, An Essay in Modal Logic and Deontic Logic, were landmarks in the postwar rise of formal modal logic and its deontic version. He was an authority on Wittgenstein, editing his later works.

Alethic-Deontic Logic: Some Theorems. Daniel Rönnedal. Abstract The purpose of this paper is to prove some theorems in alethic-deontic logic. Alethic-deontic logic is a kind of bimodal logic that combines ordinary. 2Three other texts worthy of mention are: K.

Segerberg, An Essay in Classical Modal Logic, Philosophy Society and Department of Philosophy, University of Uppsala, Vol. 13, ; and R. Bull and K. Segerberg, ‘Basic Modal Logic’, in Handbook of. An essay in deontic logic and the general theory of action: With a bibliography of deontic and imperative logic (Acta philosophica Fennica) [G.

H. von Wright] on *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers. Standard Deontic Logic (SDL) is the most cited and studied system of deontic logic, and one of the first deontic logics axiomatically specified.

It builds upon propositional logic, and is in fact essentially just a distinguished member of the most studied class of modal logics, “normal modal logics”.

An essay in deontic logic
Rated 4/5 based on 38 review